Showing posts with label premises. Show all posts
Showing posts with label premises. Show all posts

Sunday, October 20, 2019

Kiss

10.27.19

India Eisley

Kiss
Bliss
亲吻幸福 
Qīnwěn xìngfú
至福を楽しむ
Shifuku o tanoshimu
ps 65
Oscula beato

The sky is moist with air.
The courage of conviction has to be fair.

The image of our sky appears in the night
when the crescent moon is nearly out of sight.

The creativity of darkness approaches its height.


Uranus

Oversight sails on high.
Beauty gives courage an ally.

This temple was not made with human hands.
It was not built on stone. It is closer to sand
but it is on land.

Build a promise like you build a house.
Don't forget your beginning sprouts
with the tests you tout.

Prayer is answered with each test
insofar as you seek to find the best.

Start each task with the end in mind
until the next step is the tie that binds.

Courage for faith 
will pave 
the way 
to say:

"Design will be conceived.
Goals will be achieved.
Stress will be relieved.
Reward will be believed.

"Promises will be kept.
Support will not have left.
Meaning will be what was meant
with respect for the right intent."


The ominous drama of office
will honor the keeping of promise
for the honorable prominence
of love's dominance.

Salvation is a benefit for worship with prayer.
Survival blessed with goodness waits at the height of the spiral stair.

The Pastor was given the strength to deliver his message
that potential believers might hear the essence of the lesson.

The liturgy is a model for concise variation in prayer
that asks for guidance in statecraft to build on the goodness which is there.

The free exercise of religion is adverse to damage to self or others
in the psychology that respects health as a natural wonder.

Leadership is modeled on the image of divinity
when interpretation is viewed in relation to the Trinity.

The administration of the state concerns the law
as the means to reduce human flaw.

The law of the state is inferred from the design of nature
insofar as written intent is recorded by the legislature.

Attachment to asceticism can rise from religion or political inclination
but passion for punishment is harmful to the intent of investigation
or legislation.

From what premises are propositions deduced?
Isn't the evidence of the senses used? 


The dogmas of empiricism are against the inference of principle.
Logical constructs cannot stray from the expression of the clinical. 

Absurd conclusions are drawn from want of method.
The lack of definition results in what you may have expected.

Absurdities proceed from the confusion
in a way that resembles a cerebral contusion.

Forgiveness will be shown.
The drone groan will not have blown
the bliss of this kiss.
The fixable will forge forgiveness
for that which is forgivable in this.

Happiness will happen.
Welcome will be in fashion.
Reliability will protect the hallowed halls
with the brightly painted walls
of faith with fidelity
as the melody
for the clarity
of charity.

We will be satisfied in this house of satisfaction
with attraction for the action of benefaction
as the plan for action that is not just abstraction
with respect for life with liberty and the justice
that will thrust us into august robustness
with justness as our substance.

There is no partiality in impartial judgment.
Statistical inference has to rule on the budget.

Deliverance
will deliver us
from ignorance

as the construction
for destruction
and belief in being lawyers
with destroyers as employers.


Salvation is hope that reaches

by the farthest seas to the nearest beaches.

Mountains were established by the strength of land
being pressed by pressure from beyond and beneath the sands.

The roaring waves of outraged oceans
find solace in silent motions
after the purging surge of roaring rage
releases peace from the pain of the age.

That the funnel forms from the cloud to the ground in a tornado
doesn't rule out lightning as the cause of thunder in the sound before the hailstone.

Not all that is determined through the immediate perception of sense
is known as an inferable expense in the future tense.

Love for life quiets the tumult
from turbulent tides and the lightning bolt.

Merchants commission transportation for materials
and pay employees to sell products in a way defined as managerial.

Carriers are paid to navigate transportation 
with direction drawn from the stars to reach the destination.

Materials are transported from remote places around the globe
to reach the manufacturing industry for production beyond hope.

Machinery automates that which can be automated in labor.
Operators work the machines to produce products you or your neighbor
can favor. 

The morning and evening
shout for joy as gateways for retrieving
the goodness of peace that reaches
to the ultimate end that the awe of awesome teaches.

The power of the sun, wind, water and soil
make grain grow as part of the plan for the least amount of toil.

Irrigation teaches water to reach low
to each place that had not been known
by moisture or had not been shown
the blessing of growth.

Drainage drives deluge into ponds
for holding the drink for the palm's unfolding fronds.

Time is crowned by provision.
Trade, travel and labor's vision
will overflow with wealth in a provident decision
of the economy's revision of monetary division.

The land abounds with boundaries
established by pastures. forest trees,
rivers, lakes, seas, deserts and constructed levies.

Meadows are adorned with flocks.
Gates are secured with locks.

Valleys give growth to grain.
Pleasure is cultivated from pain.

Life sings for the joy of living.
This joy is strengthened with thanksgiving.

Liberty is limited by the law of love for life.
Redemption transforms adversity from strife.

Happy are those who are brought near your courts.
Security transcends the structure of the fort.

Kiss bliss.
Don't dismiss this.
It will help you to dismiss
what the Swiss missed.

Like you build a temple, like you build a statue, you build a vow...

----------------------

Psalm 65
Te decet hymnus
You are praised

To the leader. A Psalm of David. A Song.

1 Praise is due to you,
   O God, in Zion;
and to you shall vows be performed,
2   O you who answer prayer!
To you all flesh shall come.
3 When deeds of iniquity overwhelm us,
   you forgive our transgressions.
4 Happy are those whom you choose and bring near
   to live in your courts.
We shall be satisfied with the goodness of your house,
   your holy temple.
5 By awesome deeds you answer us with deliverance,
   O God of our salvation;
you are the hope of all the ends of the earth
   and of the farthest seas.
6 By your* strength you established the mountains;
   you are girded with might.
7 You silence the roaring of the seas,
   the roaring of their waves,
   the tumult of the peoples.
8 Those who live at earth’s farthest bounds are awed by your signs;
you make the gateways of the morning and the evening shout for joy.
9 You visit the earth and water it,
   you greatly enrich it;
the river of God is full of water;
   you provide the people with grain,
   for so you have prepared it.
10 You water its furrows abundantly,
   settling its ridges,
softening it with showers,
   and blessing its growth.
11 You crown the year with your bounty;
   your wagon tracks overflow with richness.
12 The pastures of the wilderness overflow,
   the hills gird themselves with joy,
13 the meadows clothe themselves with flocks,
   the valleys deck themselves with grain,
   they shout and sing together for joy.

-----------------------

Joel- YHWH believer
Penthuel- Mouth of God

Joel refrained from mentioning the current ruling kings. This omission suggests that the prophecy occurred in the aftermath of Judah’s only ruling queen, Athaliah (d. 835 BCE).

Her young grandson, Joash, succeeded Athaliah upon her death. Joash was too young to rule after her death so the priest Jehoida ruled in his place until he came of age. This presented a caretaking period in the monarchy.

If Joel prophesied during this caretaking period, it would make sense that he mentioned no official king. The book makes ample mention of priests, temple rituals and nations.

Phoenicia, Philistia, Egypt and Edom were prominent in the late ninth century BCE. All of this points to a date prior to 835 BCE or soon after. This makes Joel one of the earliest writing prophets and a  contemporary of the prophet Elisha.

The book focuses its prophetic judgment on the southern kingdom of Judah. There are a number of references to Zion and the temple worship. Joel’s familiarity with this area and the worship in the temple places him in Judah, possibly in the city of Jerusalem.

The book of Joel’s importance to the canon of Scripture stems from its being the first to develop the day of the Lord as a biblical idea that was to be mentioned often. Some of the most striking and specific details in all of Scripture are given. The days cloaked in darkness, a plague of locusts, armies that conquer like consuming fire and the moon turning to blood are listed.

The day is described as a time of divine judgment when consequence is imposed for the infidelity of immorality, but it had an immediate frame of reference for the public with the incidence of forest or building fires.

The eternal flame was a component of the Jewish religious rituals performed in the Tabernacle in the wilderness. Records show that a commandment required a fire to burn continuously upon the Outer Altar.

This flame was included in the temple after it had been built. Modern Judaism continues a similar tradition by having a sanctuary lamp, the ner tamid, always lit above the ark in the synagogue. The flame is a symbolic reminder of tragic events in history.

The eternal fire is a long-standing tradition in many cultures and religions. The Atar was tended by a dedicated priest in ancient Iran. The fire represented the concept of "divine sparks" or Amesha Spenta as understood in Zoroastrianism.

The tragedy of the past is used to predict the repetition in the future as a marker for living a good life in the present. A good life is divinely blessed.

The Day of the Lord

Joel 2:32

Everyone who calls on the name of the LORD will be saved. There shall be those who escape in Mount Zion and Jerusalem. The LORD has said, there will be those whom have been called among the survivors.

-----------------------

Salvation is a benefit for worship with prayer.
Survival blessed with goodness waits at the height of the spiral stair.

=================

Sirah, the Book of Ecclesiasticus, is a collection of ethical instructions. It closely resembles Proverbs, except that, unlike the latter, it is the work of a single author, not an anthology of maxims drawn from various sources.

It is likely that the author compiled statements drawn from a number of sources. Attribution to a single author was a movement towards the recognition of private property as a legal entity.

The premise for the organization of the sources was structured around the definition of wisdom as the fear of God. This fear is the presumed motivation for adherence to Mosaic law.

The maxims are expressed in exact formulas as illustrated by striking images. They show a profound knowledge of the human heart, the disillusionment of experience and sympathy for the poor as subject to oppression from adversity.

Two opposing tendencies are at conflict in the testimony of the author. It's like the conflict expressed in Ecclesiastes. The strength of morality as drawn from the past is at odds with that faith that holds an Epicurean desire for progress.

The prayer of Israel runs through the moral chapters imploring God to gather together his scattered children, to bring to fulfilment the predictions of the Prophets and to have mercy upon his Temple and his people.

The book concludes with a justification for faith in God whose wisdom and greatness are said to be revealed in morality and the history of Israel.

The book was written by the Jewish scribe Ben Sira of Jerusalem sometime between 200 and 175 BCE. He was inspired by his father, Joshua son of Sirach. The name Joshua can be translated as Jesus or Yeshua.

The book was translated into Greek in Egpyt by the author's unnamed grandson. The grandson added a prologue.

This prologue is generally considered the earliest witness to a canon of the books of the prophets. The date of the text has been the subject of intense scrutiny. The book itself is the largest wisdom book from antiquity to have survived.

Ecclesiasticus 35:15-16

The Lord is the judge.
There is no partiality with him.
He will not show partiality to the poor,
but he will listen to the prayer of one who is wronged.

-----------------------

There is no partiality in impartial judgment.
Statistical inference has to rule on the budget.

=================

The second letter to Timothy has been identified as 1 of 3 pastoral epistles traditionally attributed to the apostle Paul. The epistles are called "pastoral" because they relate to the conduct of church leaders. The leaders are named pastors as a figurative association with shepherds.

The Epistle advocates endurance as the main quality for a preacher of the gospel. Salvation was celebrated as deliverance from attack. The deliverance allowed for persuasion to faith in Christ Jesus as the author of the good news for the love of God in life.

The pastoral letters are different from Paul's other epistles. Scholars since the early 19th century have increasingly seen the pastorals as the work of an unknown student of Paul's doctrine.  They are believed to have been written between 90 and 140. They reflect a church hierarchy that is more organized and defined than the church was in Paul's time.

2 Timothy 4:17-18

The Lord stood by me and gave me strength that through me the message might be fully proclaimed and all the Gentiles might hear it. I was rescued from the lion's mouth. The Lord will rescue me from every evil attack and save me for his heavenly kingdom.

-----------------------

The Pastor was given the strength to deliver his message
that potential believers might hear the essence of the lesson.

=================

The 18th chapter of the gospel of Luke had presented the parable of the widow to encourage persistence in prayer. The parable of the publican and the pharisee promoted humility and concise expression in the persistence.

Luke 18:9-14

Jesus told this parable to some who trusted that they were righteous and regarded others with contempt: 'Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. The Pharisee stood by himself and prayed, "God, I thank you that I am not like other people: thieves, rogues, adulterers or even like this tax-collector. I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all my income."

'The tax-collector stood far off. He would not even look up to heaven, but beat his breast and said, "God be merciful to me, a sinner!" I tell you this man went down to his home justified rather than the other. All who exalt themselves will be humbled, but all who humble themselves will be exalted.'

-----------------------

The liturgy is a model for concise variation in prayer
that asks for guidance in statecraft to build on the goodness which is there.

=================



James wrote True Law about the same time that Richard Hooker had published the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity (1597) to defend the Elizabethan settlement. Hooker had argued that there were good and bad monarchies, democracies and church hierarchies.

Authority was to be based on reason for goodness. He called this goodness piety. The term is interchangeable with prudence or duty. It is one of the cardinal virtues in classical culture. It refers to that which is automated in behavior based on belief. The belief is derived with reason with respect for order in nature.

When authority is wrong, it has to be corrected with right reason. The correction of that policy which was established without regard for the maintenance or improvement of goodness in precedent is a duty. The logic isn't circular. It is dialectical.

James argued that knowledge of God was the basis for allegiance especially in monarchy. Rebellion strengthened error in the Commonwealth. The true ground for allegiance between the monarch and the people was mutual duty. The duty produces the benefit of freedom within the law in relation to the absolute.   

Sound instruction in truth is the true law for that which is free. Faith in God is the guide to sound instruction.

The future king of England provided the context for his argument with respect for the Bible, the kingdom and nature. The Bible was used as a historical reference that established that monarchy was a pattern for government that developed the practice of royal succession by inheritance with birth.

The first king had won monarchy in battle.The story regarding the consumption of his heirs by Saturn illustrated that the  polytheists had trouble with the establishment of a royal line.

Rebellion was viewed as a test of mettle to repeat the establishment of rule by military battle. Each heir was seen as a competitor to the authority of the crown prior to the death of the established monarch.

The Romans had done away with monarchy to insist on victory by popular election, but the term limits for the chief elected position of consul was one year for two consuls. It was an over-correction that resulted in the rise of the emperor as a position that allowed for family succession.

The Patricians who ran the senate did not approve of the innovation. They saw it as an offense to the elected leadership in the republic. They made sure that the emperor was subject to the approval of the Patricians and the Plebians.

The policy was not favorable to foreign relations insofar as monarchies were treated as anachronistic and primitive people were viewed as barbarians. Either were capable of rebellion that could overthrow the Roman extension of rule in empire.

James VI was right to identify rebellion as the cause of error for selection of leadership by royal succession or election by the commonwealth. His treatise established an argument for the use of reason in legislative reform.

James I (1566-1625)
The True Lawe of Free Monarchies (1598)
Text

"First then, I will set downe the trew grounds, whereupon I am to build, out of the Scriptures, since Monarchie is the trew paterne of Diuinitie, as I haue already said: next, from the fundamental Lawes of our owne Kingdome, which nearest must concerne vs: thirdly, from the law of Nature, by diuers similitudes drawne out of the same: and will conclude syne by answering the most waighty and appearing incommodities that can be obiected."

----------------------

"First then, I will set down the true grounds whereupon I am to build out of the Scriptures. Monarchy is the true pattern of Divinity as I have already said. Next, the fundamental Laws of our own Kingdom which are nearest must concern us. Thirdly, the law of Nature is drawn out of the same by divers similitudes. I will conclude soon by answering the most weighty and appearing incommodities that can be objected."

---------------------

Leadership is modeled on the image of divinity
when interpretation is viewed in relation to the Trinity.

The administration of the state concerns the law
as the means to reduce human flaw.

The law of the state is inferred from the design of nature
insofar as written intent is recorded by the legislature.

================



Locke wrote the Two Treatises (1689) after Hobbes' Leviathan (1651), but his work reflected the mindset that insisted that rebellion was the power over the commonwealth.

Locke's argument was a regression even though it came after what Hobbes had published. His work couldn't be published in his name during his life.

Hobbes established the development of James' biblically based argument with the social contract as a constitutional expression.

Locke wrote about the state of nature in terms of perfect freedom. His freedom was defined in terms of the liberal claim to power over the government and the people whom had elected them for representation.

Liberal power was defined in terms of the threat of terrorism or rebellion. Treason could even be defined as the threat of rebellion. The requirement that it was organized against the claim of the tyranny in executive leadership was stipulated as neccessary to control parliament and the monarchy from the House of Commons.

Hobbes defined the same state of nature as the condition of life without government in order to establish the importance of allegiance.

The first ten amendments to the US Bill of Rights were written by James Madison. The language was used in way that demonstrated that the English Bill of Rights was too particular for the power of the Whigs and Locke in expression.

The US Bill was ratified 100 years after the English form. The English Bill came 100 years after James had his work published. The American Bill displayed the ability to learn from experience. It was the first step in the reconstruction of Roman republic for their time.

The Constitutional expression would have to add the right to vote for women and people of color later to make it less particular to the majority political group.

One of the chief elements in the liberal claim to power was the admonition to reckon without words. Aristotle's law of the excluded middle was used to reduce argument for a law against slavery. The slave trade was tolerated for slavery in the colonies.

Slavery was such an offense against that which could be defined as natural law with respect for kingdom or republic in the Bible that it was an absurdity in speech. The liberals were so invested in the establishment of their power that they didn't admit to error much less abusurdity in public speech.

Hobbes felt that it was necessary to establish that right reason admit to the correction of error or absurdity to guide the application of addition or subtraction to the constitutional expression of the social contract.

Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679)
Leviathan (1651)
Text

"The first cause of Absurd conclusions I ascribe to the want of Method; in that they begin not their Ratiocination from Definitions; that is, from settled significations of their words: as if they could cast account, without knowing the value of the numerall words, One, Two, and Three.

"And whereas all bodies enter into account upon divers considerations, (which I have mentioned in the precedent chapter;) these considerations being diversly named, divers absurdities proceed from the confusion, and unfit connexion of their names into assertions."

----------------------

"The first cause of absurd conclusions I ascribe to the want of method. They don't begin with argument from definitions; that is from settled significations of their words: as if they could could cast account without knowing the value of the numeral words, one, two and three.

"Whereas all bodies enter into account upon drivers considerations, these considerations being diversely named, divers absurdities proceed from the confusion and unfit connection of their names into assertions."

----------------------

Absurd conclusions are drawn from want of method.
The lack of definition results in what you may have expected.

Absurdities proceed from the confusion
in a way that resembles a cerebral contusion.

================

The British line of succession was maintained despite the Whig argument for selection by Parliament.
Anne was the older sister to Mary. Charles II was their father. He had both of them raised as Anglicans.

Mary ascended to the throne first by virtue of the Whig favor for her husband, William of Orange, and her Protestant religion. Mary ruled with William from 1669 until her death in 1694. William remained in power until his death in 1702. They did not produce any children.

Anne was crowned in 1702. She reigned until she died in 1714. She was 49 years of age. She had not had any children.

The Act of Settlement was passed by the English Parliament in 1701.  Parliament did not choose to select the next monarch. They restricted the succession to Protestants.

The Act applied to England and Ireland. Scotland abstained. A strong minority wished to preserve the Stuart dynasty and its right of inheritance to the throne.

The Acts of Union was enacted in 1707. Anne became the Queen of both England and Scotland. The two kingdoms were united with one Parliament.

Most of the House of Stuart was Roman Catholic, but whoever was being considered to succeed to the throne had to be raised Protestant. The monarch would become the head of the Anglican Church.

Sophia of Hanover was the grand-daughter of James I. When Anne died, Sophia's son, George I, became the king. This was the start of the Hanoverian dynasty in Great Britain. There would be two foreign born monarchs before the House produced a British heir.

The Jacobite risings were attempts to restore the House of Stuart to dynastic rule.  The House of Stuart had abdicated the throne when King James II (1633–1701) fled to France in 1688. He and his son, James Francis Stuart, the Prince of Wales, claimed to be the legitimate kings.

They had support from important elements in England. King Louis XIV in France supported them as well. The main issue was religion. Catholic Europe was for the Stuarts.

The Whigs were staunch opponents of Catholicism. Protestant Europe favored them. This included the Dutch and Swiss Reforms, German Protestants and Reformed Protestants and French Protestants.

The Protestant House of Hanover starting with King George I in 1714. They were not especially popular in Britain because they were born in a foreign country.

The Jacobites plotted and attempted seaborne invasions. The major attempts were the Jacobite rising of 1715 and the Jacobite rising of 1745. Both failed to rally significant popular support. The Jacobite defeat at the Battle of Culloden in 1746 ending any realistic hope of a Stuart restoration.

Britain was one of the most prosperous countries in the world by the 1720's. The nation has a set of primary interests that distinguished them from the continental dynasties of the Habsburgs, Bourbons and the House of Hohenzollern. The main diplomatic goal was to build  a worldwide trading network for its merchants, manufacturers, shippers and financiers.

The Royal Navy was strengthened to defend shipping routes and the homeland from invasion. The London government enhanced the private sector by incorporating numerous privately financed London-based companies for establishing trading posts and opening import-export businesses across the world.

Each was given a monopoly of trade to the specified geographical region. The first enterprise was the Muscovy Company set up in 1555 to trade with Russia. The East India Company and the Hudson's Bay Company in Canada were other prominent enterprises.

Trade with Africa included slaves as well as gold and ivory. The Company of Royal Adventurers was organized after the English Civil War in 1662. it was reestablished as the Royal African Company in 1672 to focus on the slave trade.

British involvement in four major wars between 1740 to 1783 paid off in terms of trade. The loss of the 13 colonies resulted in trade relations with the United States. The slave, sugar and commercial trades in West Africa and the West Indies contributed to the dominance of the British in trade with India.

China would be next on the agenda. Other powers set up similar monopolies on a smaller scale. Only the Netherlands emphasized trade as much as England. British exports soared from £6.5 million in 1700, to £14.7 million in 1760.

Adam Smith studied social philosophy at the University of Glasgow. He studied moral philosophy under Francis Hutcheson. He developed his passion for liberty, reason and free speech at the university.

He was the graduate scholar presented to undertake postgraduate studies at Balliol College, Oxford in 1740 from a scholarship set up by the Scot John Snell. He felt that the rich endowments of the colleges at Oxford and Cambridge separated the income of the professor from the ability to attract students.

Smith wrote two classic works, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) and An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776). The work reflects on the economics at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. The major theme is unusual insofar as productivity in labor is identified as the basic building block for wealth.

Stocks, opulence, political economy and the revenue of the sovereign or commonwealth are counted as elements. 

The Wealth of Nations gained him a reputation as the Father of Capitalism. It laid the foundations of classical free market economic theory. The Wealth of Nations was a precursor to the modern academic discipline of economics.

His explanation of the division of labor is rich in detail. He described the coat of a common day laborer in terms of all the industries that were included to make the coat.

The woolen coat required the work of the shepherd, the sorter of the wool, the wool-comber or carder, the dyer, the scribbler, the spinner, the weaver, the fuller, the dresser and others.

They all joined their arts in order to complete the product. Merchants and carriers were employed to transport the materials from different parts of the country. Modern machines were employed to automate important features in the production.

Larger scale industries transferred the work from human to mechanical automation. Skilled labor was required to run the machines to reduce the costs for the operation.   

Adam Smith (1723-1790)
Wealth of Nations (1776)
Ch.1: The Division of Labour
Text

"How many merchants and carriers, besides, must have been employed in transporting the materials from some of those workmen to others who often live in a very distant part of the country? How much commerce and navigation in particular, how many ship-builders, sailors, sail-makers, rope-makers, must have been employed in order to bring together the different drugs made use of by the dyer, which often come from the remotest corners of the world? What a variety of labour, too, is necessary in order to produce the tools of the meanest of those workmen! To say nothing of such complicated machines as the ship of the sailor, the mill of the fuller, or even the loom of the weaver..."

----------------------

Merchants commission transportation for materials
and pay employees to sell products in a way defined as managerial.

Carriers are paid to navigate transportation
with direction drawn from the stars to reach the destination.

Materials are transported from remote places around the globe
to reach the manufacturing industry for production beyond hope.

Machinery automates that which can be automated in labor.
Operators work the machines to produce products you or your neighbor
can favor.

================



The two party system for Britain was formed in England in the 17th century. The Court Party and the Country Party were organized after the English Civil War.

The Court Party came to be known as the Tories. The term stuck despite the official name “Conservative.”

The Exclusion Bill crisis of 1678-1681 produced the nicknames for the respective parties. The Country Party supported the exclusion of the Duke of York for the thrones of England, Ireland and Scotland because he was Roman Catholic. The Courts opposed the bill.

Both names were originally insults. A “whiggamore” was a horse driver. A “tory” was an Irish term for an outlaw. The Conservatives are still known as Tories.

Jeremy Bentham was born in a wealthy family that supported the Tories. He studied law. He got his Bachelor's degree from Queen's College in 1763 and his master's degree in 1766. He never practiced law, but he wrote about the philosophy of law.

He spent most of his life criticizing the existing law and strongly advocating legal reform. He wrote a critical response to the Declaration of Independence. He referred to the French Rights of Man as nonsense on stilts.

He spent much of his time in intense study. He would write for 8 to 12 hours a day. He was an active polemicist.

He became associated with William Petty, the Earl of Shelburne in 1781. He came into contact with a number of the leading Whig politicians and lawyers through him. His work was admired by some, but remained largely unappreciated.

He coined the name “utilitarian” in recording a dream he had while a guest at the country estate of the Earl, his patron. He imagined himself as the founder of the sect of utilitarians. He was to be a personage of great sanctity and importance.

His major proposal was for prison reform in relation to the panopticon view of design. He had traveled to Krichev in White Russia (modern Belarus) to visit his brother, Samuel, in 1786 and 1787. Samuel was engaged in managing various industrial and other projects for Prince Potemkin.

His brother conceived the basic idea of a circular building at the hub of a larger compound as a means of allowing a small number of managers to oversee the activities of a large and unskilled workforce. Jeremy developed the model for prisons.

He outlined his ideas in a series of letters sent home to his father in England. The supervisory principle with the idea of contract management. The director of the administration would have a pecuniary interest in lowering the average rate of mortality.

The panopticon was intended to be cheaper than the prisons of his time as it required fewer staff. The proposal was the development of his utilitarian philosophy with respect for law enforcement. It was not an advocacy for hedonism. He had the utility of the national interest in mind.

The ultimately abortive proposal for a panopticon prison to be built in England was one among his many proposals for legal and social reform. He spent about 16 years of his life developing and refining his ideas for the construct.

He hoped that the government would adopt the plan for a National Penitentiary appointing him as contractor-governor. The building of a new prison in London had been authorized by the Penitentiary Act 1794 and Bentham’s plan initially received the support of the Pitt administration.

He devoted considerable sums of his own money to the project over the years. He published further material comparing the merits of the panopticon with the disadvantages of the system of transporting convicts to penal colonies

The prison was never built, but the concept had an important influence on later generations of thinkers. He was given £23,000 compensation for his work on the proposal.

His most important theoretical work was the Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789). His moral theory reflected "the greatest happiness principle" as the logical basis for legislation.

The theory was developed out of empiricism with references to statements by Locke and Hume.
The notion that pleasure and pain are the universal bases from which the principle of utility was derived is a development of what Locke had said about the state of nature as perfect freedom. Hume's philosophy of history was used to endorse the concept of psychological egoism for self-interest.

Bentham identified two classes of ascetics who were opposed to the utility of happiness in legislation. One class was moral. The other was religious. He observed that the religious party had been less wise with respect for government. The religionists not only courted pain as a product of asceticism, they used the principle to impose misery with punishment by the affliction on others.

While Locke had distanced himself from biblical reason in the metaphor of Adam as a reference to the development of monarchy out of tribal life, his association with Aristotle was tied into the justification for the Crusades, the Inquisition and slavery by the position that there were those who were meant to rule and those who were meant to be ruled.

The same cruelty towards people appeared to be the case in the Ottoman rule as well.
The Puritans weren't exactly pure when it came to government in local councils, but the religiousity of the Whig party had broader and more harmful applications on the political order.

Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832)
Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789)
Text

"It is true, that from the same source from whence, among the religionists, the attachment to the principle of asceticism took its rise, flowed other doctrines and practices, from which misery in abundance was produced in one man by the instrumentality of another: witness the holy wars, and the persecutions for religion. But the passion for producing misery in these cases proceeded upon some special ground: the exercise of it was confined to persons of particular descriptions: they were tormented, not as men, but as heretics and infidels."

----------------------

Attachment to asceticism can rise from religion or political inclination
but passion for punishment is harmful to the intent of legislation.

================



When freedom is used in relation to religion, it welcomes the consideration of variety to value the meaning of faith in the context of the believer's religion. Religion is moved from a closed system to one where growth is possible personally and socially. This concept rests at the heart of classical reconstruction.

The proposal to move from polytheism to monotheism held the social value of moving from primitive to civilized life. Civilized life holds the promise that comes with association by allegiance to law in the political body.

Freedom of religion is only one element in the First Amendment, but it is socially and personally significant in political application.

James Madison re-wrote English documents on administrative structure in government for the US Constitution. It was ratified in 1788. He also re-wrote the English Bill of Rights. The American form was ratified in 1791. He edited the content for the public by the removal of expression that was too favorable to any faction.

The Federalist Papers were written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay. The Papers are a collection of 85 articles and essays. They were written under the pseudonym "Publius" to promote the ratification fo the US Constitution.

The first 77 of these essays were published serially in the Independent Journal, the New York Packet and The Daily Advertiser between October 1787 and April 1788. The last eight papers (Nos. 78–85) were republished in the New York newspapers between June 14 and August 16, 1788.

The authors explicitly stated that they were looking at the establishment of good government by "reflection and choice." This was presented in contrast to the general notion that political constitutions are determined by accident and force.

Federalist No. 10 is the most important of the 85 articles from a philosophical perspective. Madison discussed the means to prevent rule by majority faction. He advocated for a commerical republic for the promotion of employment in trade.

The proposed Constitution was ratified by the minimum 9 states stipulated in Article VII on June 21, 1788. The process of organizing the new government began when 11 states had agreed to the proposal by the end of July 1788.

The use of debate in journals published by some major media outlets contributed to the controversy that helped the public consideration of the ideas for reflection and choice.

The Federalist collection has been used by judges to interpret constitutional law. Chief Justice John Marshall noted in McColloch v. Maryland that the right to judge the correctness of the opinions expressed by the authors had to be retained for the progress of government.

The Federalist had been quoted 291 times in Supreme Court decisions by 2000.

While the source documents for the US Constitution and the Bill of Rights were written in English, the English were engaged in the controversial consideration of the political ideas that had shaped European culture. 

The Declaration of Independence had declared independence from the tyranny of monarchy.
Reflection and choice in political participation could make the difference between a successful government that facilitated trade and a tyrannical republic determined by accident and force.

Freedom of Religion was one of the key elements in the First Amendment. It stipulated that Congress will make no law for the establishment of religion nor to prevent free exercise.

Bentham's objection to the use of the force of asceticism on government decisions is relevant in a broad context. It represents disagreement with immoral morality or the domination of government by a religious faction, even the predominant kind.

Locke's liberal proposal was that political power from the larger body is expressed with the threat of rebellion over the higher authority. Force and accident are favored by this form.

The Whigs in general supported the establishment of religion for the Puritan dominance and the 'moral' norm that punishment controls public dissent. The punishment included the death penalty. torture, invasion, colonial expansion with military conquest, the threat of genocide and slavery.

The native American population was reduced to 1% of the total with this political policy. The natives were either killed by disease, in battle or by massacre. It is likely that many chose to migrate to Mexico, South America or Asian countries for protection. 

The objection to the Crusades as an example of papal supremacy stands against the invasion of foreign nations, yet their is no national law legislated against invasion as an act of aggression.

Josiah Royce recommended a definition of religion that had a moral code, allowed for devotion for observation and demonstrated value for belief. His philosophy of religion was expressed as the religious aspect of philosophy.

It was pragmatic. It provided a general definition for religion. It was drawn from the work of William James, but Royce felt that James placed too much emphasis on the extraordinary experience for an individual. He felt that an emphasis on community was necessary to define the social value of religion.

Richard Hooker's observation that there are good and bad ecclesiastical hierarchies applies to religion. Opposition to insurrection, cruelty in punishment, violent aggression and invasion stand as qualifiers of goodness in the moral code for a religion.

William James stipulated that his interest in religion was psychological from a medical perspective. He was trained in medical art. His approach was therapeutic, not political or legislative against establishment. It was for free exercise.

Freedom is qualified legally and morally as against causing damage to self or others.

William James (1842-1910)
Varieties of Religious Experience (1902)
Text

"If the inquiry be psychological, not religious institutions, but rather religious feelings and religious impulses must be its subject, and I must confine myself to those more developed subjective phenomena recorded in literature produced by articulate and fully self-conscious men, in works of piety and autobiography. Interesting as the origins and early stages of a subject always are, yet when one seeks earnestly for its full significance, one must always look to its more completely evolved and perfect forms. It follows from this that the documents that will most concern us will be those of the men who were most accomplished in the religious life and best able to give an intelligible account of their ideas and motives."

----------------------

The free exercise of religion is adverse to damage to self or others
in the psychology that respects health as a natural wonder.

================



Pragmatism began in the United States around 1870. The product of a belief was regarded as the practical value. Peirce defined the practical effects of a conception as that which defined the object.
It continued to be a dominant movement in philosophy during the early decades of the 20th century. Other movements and schools of thought emerged.

George Santayana (1863-1952) was a student of Josiah Royce. He studied at Harvard University. He went to Berlin before returning to write his dissertation and to teach. His dissertation was on Hermann Lotze, a German logician with a degree in medicine. He studied at King's College, Cambridge from 1896 to 1897.

He published The Life of Reason in 1906. His idea of common sense defined an ideal as having a natural basis. Everything natural has an ideal development. It wasn't a rejection of idealism. The biological perspective of history was added. This placed idealism in the framework of common sense.

He described reason in common sense, society, religion, art and science. His explanation of religion was conditioned by reason in experience. A little philosophy could incline someone's mind to atheism. Depth in philosophy brings thought to reflection about religion. The God that inspires atheism is different from the one for depth in wisdom.

He resigned his position at Harvard in 1912. He spent the rest of his life writing in Europe and living on his inheritance.

The influence of John Dewey (1859–1952) and his friend Jane Addams (1860–1935) was immense. Jane Addams invented the profession of social work as an expression of pragmatist ideas. She was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1931.

George Herbert Mead (1863–1931) was also of considerable importance. He contributed significantly to the social sciences. Pragmatist perspectives upon the relations between the self and the community were developed.

When the progressive Deweyan ‘New Deal’ era passed away, the US moved into the Cold War. Pragmatism’s influence was challenged. Analytic philosophy blossomed and became the dominant methodological orientation in most Anglo-American philosophy departments.

Transitional or ‘third generation’ figures included C.I. Lewis and W.V.O. Quine. These philosophers developed a number of pragmatist themes, but their analytic allegiance may be seen in their significant focus on theory of knowledge as first philosophy. Dewey had deprecated this view as ‘the epistemological industry’.

The analytic school of philosophy started to dominate academic philosophy early in the 20th century. This was most notable in Great Britain and the United States. It originated as G. E. Moore and Bertrand Russell broke away from Absolute Idealism. Absolute idealism had been a leading school in the British universities. Gottlob Frege was also regarded as a founder of the analytic movement in the late 19th century.

The middle of the 20th century was the beginning of the dominance of analytic philosophy in America. Analytic philosophy had begun in Europe with the work of Gottlob Frege, Bertrand Russell, Ludwig Wittgenstein and the logical positivists.

The truths of logic and mathematics are tautologies according to logical positivism. Those of science are empirically verifiable. Any other claim, including the claims of ethics, aesthetics, theology, metaphysics and ontology are meaningless. This theory is called verificationism.

Many positivists fled Germany to Britain and America with the rise of Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party. This helped reinforce the dominance of analytic philosophy in the United States in subsequent years.

W.V.O. Quine was an American logician who was affiliated with Harvard from 1930 until his death in 2000.

He was not a logical positivist, but he shared their view that philosophy should stand  with science in its pursuit of intellectual clarity and understanding of the world. He criticized the logic the analytic/synthetic distinction of knowledge drawn by the positivists in his essay "Two Dogmas of Empiricism". He also criticized the reduction of logic to immediate experience.

He advocated for his "web of belief". The web was for coherent belief in justification. No experience occurs in isolation in Quine's epistemology. The theory is actually a holistic approach to knowledge where every belief or experience is intertwined with the whole. Quine is also famous for inventing the term "gavagai" as part of his theory of the indeterminacy of translation.

Quine opened his statement against the two dogmas with the critical analysis of empiricism. This questioned the dogma that was being used to define experience. The logical positivist rejection of metaphysics prevented the use of science to infer statements of metaphysical import.

Logical positivism didn't allow people to investigate the claims of science with respect to philosophy. It basically left anti-religious sentiment as the product of critical analysis in empiricism. They disagreed with the proposal of anything even if it was derived from scientific investigation.

W.V.O Quine (1908-2000)
Two Dogmas of Empiricism (1953)
Text

"Modern empiricism has been conditioned in large part by two dogmas. One is a belief in some fundamental cleavage between truths which are analytic, or grounded in meanings independently of matters of fact and truths which are synthetic, or grounded in fact. The other dogma is reductionism: the belief that each meaningful statement is equivalent to some logical construct upon terms which refer to immediate experience. Both dogmas, I shall argue, are ill founded. One effect of abandoning them is, as we shall see, a blurring of the supposed boundary between speculative metaphysics and natural science. Another effect is a shift toward pragmatism."

----------------------

The dogmas of empiricism are against the inference of principle.
Logical constructs cannot stray from the expression of the clinical.

================



A. J. Ayer
b. 10.29.1910  London, England
d. 6.27.1989 London, England

A.J. Ayers was an English philosopher known for his promotion of logical positivism. He argued against transcendental idealism in Language, Truth, and Logic (1936). The book brought the ideas of the Vienna Circle and the logical empiricists to the English speaking world.

The verification principle asserted that only statements that are empirically verifiable are meaningful. Metaphysical statements were designated as meaningless.

Ayer saw himself as a representative of the line of British empiricism with George Berkeley and David Hume. The most recent representatives for him were Bertrand Russell and Ludwig Wittgenstein.

He argued in The Problem of Knowledge (1956) that the conditions for something as the case were that what was said is known to be true, that there was certainty regarding the truth and there was the right to be sure.

London

The years between Queen Victoria's death in 1901 and the start of the First World War in 1914 were years of growth and general prosperity. The inequalities which had characterized Victorian London continued.

One out of five Britons lived in London by 1900. The population of roughly 5 million in 1900 rose to over 7 million by 1911.

Representatives of various trade unions and of the Independent Labour Party, Fabian Society and Social Democratic Federation agreed to form a Labour Party backed by the unions and with its own whips in 1900.

The Labour Representation Committee was founded with Keir Hardie as its leader. At the 1900 general election, The LRC won only two seats at the 1900 general election. The SDF disaffiliated, but more unions signed up.

The LRC affiliated to the Socialist International. The name was changed to the Labour Party in 1906. It formed an electoral pact with the Liberals. The intent was to cause maximum damage to the Unionist government at the forthcoming election. Twenty nine Labour MPs were elected to the House of Commons.

Edwardian London was characterized principally by the burgeoning Women's Suffrage movement. The nationwide movement was spearheaded by Emmeline Pankhurst and her Women's Social and Political Union. Protests and demonstrations intensified during these years. Tension reached a peak between 1912 and 1914 as the movement militarized.

The introduction of the new 'Dreadnought' class battleship and the subsequent naval arms race with Germany prompted David Lloyd George, the chancellor of the exchequer, to introduce a tax on land, to increase income tax and to propose a 'super-tax' on incomes over £5,000 per annum in 1909. He presented these increases as designed to fund social reforms.

The Conservative-dominated House of Lords broke the parliamentary convention that the upper house should not overturn a financial bill when Chancellor David Lloyd George's budget was rejected in 1909. This ensured that House of Lords reform was one of the issues at stake in the next general election.

The election precipitated by the Lords' rejection of the 'People's Budget' resulted in 275 seats for the Liberals, 273 for the Conservatives and 40 for Labour. The budget was then passed. The Irish Nationalists were now in a position to force Irish 'Home Rule' back up the agenda with 82 seats.

Edward VII died in 1910. His son, George V, ensured that the monarchy was more active than it had been in the latter years of Victoria's reign. Edward's funeral brought the royalty of Europe for the last time before war broke out in 1914. Many of the European royals were family relations.

A.J. Ayer

Alfred Jules Ayer was born in St John's Wood in north west London on 29 October 1910. His family was wealthy. They were from continental Europe. His mother, Reine Citroën, was from the Dutch-Jewish family who founded the Citroën car company in France. His father, Jules Ayer, was a Swiss Calvinist financier who worked for the Rothschild family.

Ayer was educated at Ascham St Vincent's School. St. Vincent's was a former boarding preparatory school for boys in the seaside town of Eastbourne in Sussex. He started boarding at the comparatively early age of seven due to the First World War. He won a scholarship to Eaton College when he was 13.

It was at Eton that Ayer became known for his characteristic bravado and precocity. He was keen on sports, particularly rugby. He reputedly played the Eton Wall Game very well.

Ayer was ranked second in his year in the final examinations at Eton. He was first in classics. He unsuccessfully campaigned for the abolition of corporal punishment at the school as a member of Eton's senior council in his final year.

He won a classics scholarship to Christ Church College of Oxford University in 1929. There he studied Greek and philosophy. One of his tutors was Gilbert Ryle. He suggested that Ayer read Ludwig Wittgenstein’s Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus.

He traveled to Vienna in 1933 to meet with Moritz Schlick and other members of the Vienna Circle of logical positivists. He was one of only two English-speaking people to meet and study with the Vienna Circle. W. V. O. Quine was the other.

Ayer was elected to a five-year research fellowship at Christ Church in 1935. He finished writing Language, Truth, and Logic in that year. The book brought some of the ideas of the Vienna Circle and the logical empiricists to the attention of the English-speaking world.

He argues for the verification principle of logical positivism. This principle is referred to as the criterion of significance or criterion for meaning. Ayer explains how the principle of verifiability may be applied to the problems of philosophy.

The metaphysical thesis that philosophy affords us knowledge of a transcendent reality was rejected. Unless logical or empirical verification is possible, statements like "God exists" or "charity is good" are not true or untrue but meaningless.

Ayer became strongly involved in politics in the pre WWII years. He supported the Republican side in the Spanish Civil War. He considered joining the Communist Party, but became instead an active member of the British Labour party. He joined the Welsh Guards when WWII broke out and worked for a time interrogating prisoners.

He was Grote Professor of the Philosophy of Mind and Logic at University College London from 1946 until 1959. He returned to Oxford to become Wykeham Professor of Logic at New College.
He was president of the Aristotelian Society from 1951 to 1952 and knighted in 1970. He was known for his advocacy of humanism, and was the first executive director of the British Humanist Association (now known as Humanists UK).

Ayer wrote an article entitled, "What I saw when I was dead" in 1988 shortly before his death. He described an unusual near-death experience. The attending physician claimed in 2001 that Ayer had confided to him: "I saw a Divine Being. I'm afraid I'm going to have to revise all my books and opinions." His son Nick, however, said that he had never mentioned this to him. He found the words to be extraordinary though.

-----------------------

“One way of attacking a metaphysician who claimed to have knowledge of a reality which transcended the phenomenal world would be to inquire from what premises his propositions were deduced. Must he not begin, as other men do, with the evidence of his senses? And if so, what valid process of reasoning can possible lead him to the conception of a transcendental reality? Surely from empirical premises nothings whatsoever concerning the properties, or even the existence, of anything super-empirical can legitimately be inferred.”

------------------------

From what premises are propositions deduced?
Isn't the evidence of the senses used?

==============

Ayer was against the transcendental idealism of Kant but didn’t rule out Hegelian argument in Marxist form. He was socialist who had ruled out communism as extreme, but was a member of the Labour Party.

Socialism was seen as necessary to correct ‘Capitalist’ excess. This was the case on the European mainland and in the leftist elements in Parliamentarian politics.

Marx had made certain statements that indicated that religion was rife ground for recruits to socialism, but there was a pronounced anti-religious trend in socialist ideology. This made logical positivism aggressively anti-religious in political representation.

Their separation of Church and State was absolute. It didn’t allow for the free exercise of religion or recognition in participation in the political world. The Proletariat was too important.

This reduced the value of his logical empiricism insofar as the proposition of empirical statements from those with a religious affiliation was not regarded as possible.

------------------------

Alfred Ayer
S. 阿尔弗雷德·艾尔斯
T. 阿爾弗雷德·艾爾斯

阿 A    flatter              阿   A        flatter         A       あ   ア          Al    알  egg
尔 er   you                  爾   ji          you            ru     る    ル          peu 프  f                     
弗 fu   not                   弗  futsu   dollar         fu     ふ    フ           le    레  re         
雷 lei  terrific             雷  rai         thunder    re    れっ レッ        deu 드 de             
德 de  favor                德 toku      ethics        do   どえ  ドエ        E     에  on
艾  Ai  to reap             艾 kai         moxa        Ah   あ-   ア-         eo   어  uh       
尔  er  you                   爾 ji            you           zu    ず     ズ           seu  스  s               
斯  si   this                    斯 shi         this                   

----------------------

That the funnel forms from the cloud to the ground in a tornado
doesn't rule out lightning as the cause of thunder in the sound before the hailstone.

Not all that is determined through the immediate perception of sense
is known as an inferable expense in the future tense.

================

Language, Truth and Logic
wiki Language, Truth and Logic
Text: Language, Truth and Logic
Text: Foundations of Empirical Knowledge

-------------------------

The Military and the Declaration of War

The definition of Congress as the power that declares war is subversive. The war powers article was written when there was no standing military. It needs to be replaced with something that reflects the security of the nation.

There is an army clause in the Constitution. [Article I, Section 8, Clause 12], but it has a limit to the duration in organization. The limitation needs to be removed. The war powers article could simply be repealed at this point in time.

The liberal power of the deep state has awarded authority to those who attack the people by their claim to authority over the president. The separation of powers is not sustained by making war the basis for bi-lateral agreement between extremist factions.

The war powers article stands as the source for all the news that is used to justify action. The lack of written legislation for a standing armed force has been used to authorize many wars to justify an established military.

It allowed for the invasion of the Middle East, when negotiation and the use of counter-terrorist units as allowed by the foreign government in the particular area of concern would have been more practical and reasonable as a military response.

History of US Army
wiki Early National Period

The Continental Army was disbanded as part of the American distrust of standing armies after the Revolutionary War. Irregular state militias became the new nation's sole ground army, with the exception of a regiment to guard the Western Frontier and one battery of artillery guarding West Point's arsenal.

The Legion of the United States, was established between June and Nov. 1792 at Fort Lafayette, Pennsylvania, under Major Gen. "Mad" Anthony Wayne. The newly formed Legion moved in Dec. 1792 to an encampment downriver on the Ohio near Fort McIntosh named Legionville to train.

The Legion moved by barge down the Ohio to a camp named Hobson's Choice two miles from Fort Washington (Cincinnati) on the western frontier In September 1793. There it was joined by units from the Kentucky Militia.

Their assignment was to advance to the site of St. Clair's earlier defeat, recover the cannons lost there and continue to the Miami capital at Kekionga to establish U.S. sovereignty over northern and western Ohio and beyond.

The Legion was renamed the United States Army after Wayne's death in 1796.

Wednesday, March 20, 2019

Limit

3.21.19

Limit
Freedom
限制自由 
Xiànzhì zìyóu
自由を制限する 
Jiyū o seigen suru
ps119

Limit your freedom with responsibility.
It builds ability 
with utility 
in civility.

Trust in the Word is not absurd
when value in meaning is heard.

Love with kindness develops comfort in knowledge.
Promise is made for or drawn from something solid. 

Your letters shape words to form sentences.
Sentences make premises. 

Premises establish reason with respect for difference.
Conclusion is drawn to develop progression against menace.

Judgment is drawn as a conclusion.
Correction is aimed at reducing confusion.

Let fear steer action to safety.
What did responsibility make of me?

Reason for benefit helps with repentance.
Repentance reinforces strength in forming sentences.

Emotion plays a role in the reason of morality.
Responsibility gains definition with respect for locality.

Constitutional thought is my delight.
Conservation measures utility for what is right.


Let my heart be sound in your statutes
that I may not find shame in those roots.

My soul has longed for your salvation.
I have put my hope in your generation.

I have felt like a skin suit in smoke
but I did not see the law as a joke.

Let my heart be sound in your statutes
that I may not find shame in those roots.

Let those who attempt to enslave be put to shame.
Courage shows respect for the rules of the game.

The deceptive have staged events against me.
They don't respect order in the land of the free.

They had almost made an end of my existence.
I have gone the distance without rebellion for resistance.

How long must I wait
to set the record straight?

My eyes are watching for your promise.
The search for truth helps to keep me honest.

My sight has seen the salvation
that you have prepared for the nation.

You are a light of revelation to those who don't believe.
Christ is the glorious incarnation for those who already see. 

Your security is actually factual.
You help me to be factually actual.  

If the roots of the holly are whole
then the leaves stay green even in snow.

A little yeast leavens the whole loaf. 
Once baked, the leavened loaf contributes to growth.

Agriculture is the industry of the land.
Art and manufacturing make products the band of hands expand.

Revive me with your loving kindness
that I may grow in your likeness.

What lasts forever?
The word of truth withstands inclement weather.

Faith extends beyond each generation.
The earth abides with orbital rotation.

These continue to this day.
Each moment extends time in this way.

Fate opposes destiny in the reach of time.
The transcendence of menace is sublime.

If my delight had not been in your law
I would have perished with my flaw.

The divine design in nature
is the safest bet to wager.

A word is defined with another word or words with respect for generalization.
Panopticon sees all within reasonable expectation of visual sensation.
Abstraction doesn’t extend authority beyond legal relation. 

Legislated law had threatened to use the death penalty for any crime.
The command to love adjusts punishment to work for correction as an enzyme.

The support for restraint in reform
kept the horse quiet during the storm.

I study your law to find reason for the commandments.
Flaws in constitutional law require amendment.

There is a responsibility to avoid the cause of damage.
The organization of material helps me to manage 
my vantage.

The immaterial has material value
when no thing-ness is used to reflect on the shallow.

The shallowness of perception taps perspective 
to gauge the truth of that which is detected.

The value of money is dependent upon gold.
The beauty of a jewel has a value untold.



119:73-96
Yodh Manus tuæ fecerunt me

10th letter in the Semitic abjads
Yodh- hand -
Hebrew- Yud- יוֹד - Yud - ten

73 Your hands have made me and fashioned me;
give me understanding, that I may learn your commandments.

----------------------------

Your letters have shaped words to form sentences.
Sentences made premises.
Premises established reason with respect for difference.
Conclusion was drawn to develop progression against menace.
Reason for benefit helped with repentance.
Repentance reinforced strength in forming sentences.

====================

74 Those who fear you will be glad when they see me,
because I trust in your word.

----------------------------

Trust in your word is not absurd
when value in meaning is heard.

====================

75 I know, O Lord, that your judgments are right
and that in faithfulness you have afflicted me.

----------------------------

Judgment is drawn as a conclusion.
Correction is aimed at reducing confusion.

====================

76 Let your loving-kindness be my comfort,
as you have promised to your servant.

----------------------------

Love with kindness develops comfort in knowledge.
Promise is made for or drawn from something solid.

====================

77 Let your compassion come to me, that I may live,
for your law is my delight.

----------------------------

Constitutional thought is my delight.
Conservation measures use for what is right.

====================

78 Let the arrogant be put to shame, for they wrong me with lies;
but I will meditate on your commandments.

----------------------------

Let those who attempt to enslave be put to shame.
Courage shows respect for the rules of the game.

====================

79 Let those who fear you turn to me,
and also those who know your decrees.

----------------------------

Let fear steer action to safety.
What did responsibility make of me?

====================

80 Let my heart be sound in your statutes,
that I may not be put to shame.

----------------------------

Let my heart be sound in your statutes
that I may not find shame in those roots.

====================

Kaph Defecit in salutare

11th abjad
Kaph- palm
Hebrew- kaf- כָּף‬  - grip

81 My soul has longed for your salvation;
I have put my hope in your word.

----------------------------

My soul has longed for your salvation.
I have put my hope in your generation.

====================

82 My eyes have failed from watching for your promise,
and I say, "When will you comfort me?"

----------------------------

My eyes are watching for your promise.
The search for truth helps to keep me honest.

====================

83 I have become like a leather flask in the smoke,
but I have not forgotten your statutes.

----------------------------

I have felt like a skin suit in smoke
but I did not see the law as a joke.

====================

84 How much longer must I wait?
when will you give judgment against those who persecute me?

----------------------------

How long must I wait
to set the record straight?

====================

85 The proud have dug pits for me;
they do not keep your law.

----------------------------

The despotic have staged events against me.
They don't respect order in the land of the free.

====================

86 All your commandments are true;
help me, for they persecute me with lies.

----------------------------

Your security is actually factual.
You help me to be factually actual.

====================

87 They had almost made an end of me on earth,
but I have not forsaken your commandments.

----------------------------

They had almost made an end of my existence.
I have gone the distance without rebellion for resistance.

====================

88 In your loving-kindness, revive me,
that I may keep the decrees of your mouth.

----------------------------

Revive me in your loving kindness
that I may grow in your likeness.

====================

Lamedh In ֶternum, Domine
12th abjad
Hebrew- Lamed- לָמֶד- student

89 O Lord, your word is everlasting;
it stands firm in the heavens.

----------------------------

What lasts forever?
The word of truth withstands inclement weather.

====================

90 Your faithfulness remains from one generation to another;
you established the earth, and it abides.

----------------------------

Faith extends beyond each generation.
The earth abides with orbital rotation.

====================

91 By your decree these continue to this day,
for all things are your servants.

----------------------------

These continue to this day.
Each moment extends time in this way.
Fate opposes destiny in the reach of time.
The transcendence of menace is sublime.

====================

92 If my delight had not been in your law,
I should have perished in my affliction.

----------------------------

If my delight had not been in your law
I would have perished with my flaw.
The divine design in nature
is the safest bet to wager.

====================

93 I will never forget your commandments,
because by them you give me life.

----------------------------

Legislated law had threatened to use the death penalty for any crime.
The command to love adjusts punishment to work for correction as a social enzyme.

====================

94 I am yours; oh, that you would save me!
for I study your commandments.

----------------------------

I study your law to find reason for the commandments.
Flaws in constitutional law require amendment.

====================

95 Though the wicked lie in wait for me to destroy me,
I will apply my mind to your decrees.

----------------------------

There is a responsibility to avoid the cause of damage.
The organization of material helps me to manage
my vantage.

====================

96 I see that all things come to an end,
but your commandment has no bounds.

----------------------------

The immaterial has material value
when no thing-ness is used to reflect on the shallow.
The shallowness of perception taps perspective
to gauge the truth of that which is detected.

====================

Rom. 11:16
If the part of the dough offered as first is holy, then the whole batch is holy. If the root is holy, then the branches also are holy.

----------------------------

A little yeast leavens the whole loaf.
Once baked, the leavened loaf contributes to growth.

If the roots of the holly are whole
then the leaves stay green in snow.

====================

Luke 2:30-32
My eyes have seen your salvation
which you have prepared in the presence of all people;
a light for revelation to the Gentiles
and for glory to your people Israel.

----------------------------

My eyes have seen the salvation
that you have prepared for the nation.

You are a light of revelation to those who don't believe.
You are the glorious incarnation for those who already see.

====================

George Berkeley
Principles of Human Knowledge
1710

“… it is thought that every name has, or ought to have, ONE ONLY precise and settled signification, which inclines men to think there are certain ABSTRACT, DETERMINATE IDEAS that constitute the true and only immediate signification of each general name; and that it is by the mediation of these abstract ideas that a general name comes to signify any particular thing. Whereas, in truth, there is no such thing as one precise and definite signification annexed to any general name, they all signifying indifferently a great number of particular ideas.”

----------------------------------

A word is defined with another word or words with respect for generalization.
Panopticon sees all within reasonable expectation of visual sensation.
Abstraction doesn’t extend authority beyond legal relation.

=====================

Adam Smith
Wealth of Nations
1776

"The policy of some nations has given extraordinary encouragement to the industry of the country; that of others to the industry of towns. Scarce any nation has dealt equally and impartially with every sort of industry. Since the down-fall of the Roman empire, the policy of Europe has been more favourable to arts, manufactures, and commerce, the industry of towns, than to agriculture, the Industry of the country."

-------------------------------------

Agriculture is the industry of the land.
Art and manufacturing make products the band of hands expand.

===========================

3.21.19
The Case for Goodness

The tree must be healthy to bring forth good fruit. People are protected by the spirit and grace of God to produce beneficial works.

Justification by Faith for Good Work


The English Reformation History

Renunciation Text

Execution: Text for the Final Renunciation


Thomas Cranmer
7.2.1489 Aslockton, Nottinghamshire, England
3.21.1556 Oxford, Oxfordshire, England

Aslockton

Aslockton is in the central part of England. It is 12 miles east of Nottingham in Nottinghamshire.
Nottinghamshire lies on the Roman Fosse Way. The Fosse Way ran from the port city of Exeter in southwest England to Lincoln in Lincolnshire. Lincolnshire is on the eastern coast in the center of England. It is about 293 km (182 m.).

It is never more than 6 miles from a straight line. The road may have started as a ditch dug by Roman soldiers. The name is derived from the Latin Fossa, meaning ditch. It marked the western border for the Romans for the first few decades after the invasion in 43 CE.

Evidence of Roman settlements and forts remain in Nottinghamshire. There are earthworks for the castle of Aslockton. The earth mound or motte that bolstered the side of the castle is about 5 m (16 ft.) high.

The county had been settled by Angles around the 5th century. It became part of the Kingdom of Mercia. Mercia became an earldom later. There is evidence of Saxon settlement at the Broxtowe Estate in Oxton near Nottingham and Tuxford, east of Sherwood Forest.

Aslockton contains the Old Norse name Aslakr. The -ton in the suffix indicates that it was a place owned by Aslakr. The name appears in the Domesday survey of 1086 as Aslachetone. There are other Norse names in the county.

The population for the town was only 1,742 in the 2011 census.

Thomas Cranmer
1489-1556

Thomas was the Archbishop of Canterbury from 1533 to 1555. He served a leader of the English Reformation with Henry VIII, Edward VI and Mary I for a short time. He helped build the case for the annulment of Henry's marriage to Catherine of Aragon. He supported the principle of Royal Supremacy as a counter to Papal Supremacy.

The Roman empire had grown to encompass Europe with the many different languages. It was looking to expand in the competition with the Ottomans in the Middle East.

Slavery was made into an issue by the resurrection of the classical philosophers in the Renaissance. The emperor of the Roman empire had documented an opinion against slavery, but it was allowed in practice.

The legal code for empire was being called into question.  Torture and the death penalty  were allowed as punishment for crime since before Babylonian times. It was too punitive to be regarded as a correction, so it was identified as a deterrent.

The death penalty for crimes like theft or adultery was both final and too severe. Something had to be done to change the code, but the parliamentary body was responsible for the change in the legislation.

The task was no easy matter. The members of parliament in respective nations had to agree to both what needed to be changed and how it needed to be amended. The role of marriage in royal succession was large enough to call for attention from the religious leader in each language group.

Cranmer's contribution was not only significant with respect for Henry's marriage. He contributed to the publication of works in the English language that would help to build consensus with respect for the code of law.

Thomas was born in Aslockton, Nottinghamshire, England on 2 July 1489. He was the son of the elder Thomas by his wife, Agnes Hatfield. His parents were minor gentry. His father only had enough land to give to the eldest son John. Thomas and his younger brother, Edmund, joined the clergy.

Thomas was given a fellowship at Jesus College, Cambridge. He lost the fellowship when he married the daughter of a local innkeeper. He was re-accepted by the college when she died in childbirth. He devoted himself to study and took holy orders in 1523. He received his doctor of divinity degree in 1526.

Cranmer had made marginal notes that expressed favor for Erasmus over Martin Luther during his period of study.

Cardinal Wolsey, the king's Lord Chancellor, selected several Cambridge scholars to be diplomats in Europe. Thomas was chosen to take a minor role in the English embassy in Spain.

Two letters written by Cranmer have recently been discovered. They describe an early encounter with the king. When the king interviewed Cranmer personally for half an hour after his return from Spain in June 1527, he was observed to be "the kindest of princes."

Henry VIII's first marriage had its origins in 1502. Arthur, his elder brother died. Henry VII, betrothed Arthur's widow, Catherine of Aragon, to the future king.

The betrothal raised questions as to the biblical injunction against marriage to a brother's wife.

Lev. 20:21
If a man takes his brother's wife, it is an unclean thing. He has uncovered his brother's nakedness. They shall remain childless.

The couple married. A daughter, Mary, was born in 1516 after a series of miscarriages.
Henry did not have a son to name as a successor by the 1520's. He took this as a sign of divine anger and made overtures to the Vatican about an annulment.

Cardinal Wolsey was given the task of prosecuting the case. Cranmer assisted with the proceedings in addition to his duties as a Cambridge don from 1527.

Cranmer stayed with relatives in Waltham Holy Cross in Essex to avoid an outbreak of the plague in Cambridge in the summer of 1529. Two of his Cambridge associates joined him.

Cranmer proposed to put aside the legal case in Rome in order to canvass opinions from university theologians around Europe.

Henry showed interest in the idea when it was presented by the two associates. Thomas More was his new Lord Chancellor. It is not known whether the two explicitly approved the plan. It was implemented eventually.

Edward Foxe was one of the associates. He led the research effort. The team produced The Sufficiently Abundant Collections and The Determinations. The works provided theological and historical evidence that supported the position that the king exercised supreme jurisdiction within his realm.

Cranmer's first contact with a Continental reformer was with Simon Grynaeus. He was a humanist based in Basel, Switzerland. Simon followed the Swiss reformers Zwingli and Oecolampadius.

Grynaeus took an extended leave to visit England to offer himself as an intermediary for the king and the Continental reformers. He started a friendship with Cranmer. This early contact initiated Cranmer's relationship with Swiss and Strasbourg reformers.

Cranmer was appointed the resident ambassador at the court of the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V in January 1532. He followed the emperor to his residence in Regensburg, Bavaria as Charles traveled through his realm.

When he passed through the Lutheran city of Nuremberg, he saw the effects of the Reformation. The Imperial Diet had been moved to Nuremberg in the summer. He met the architect of the Nuremberg reforms, Andreas Osiander. They became friends.

Cranmer married Margarete, the niece of Osiander's wife, that July. The prevailing custom was for celibate priests to take a mistress when the celibacy became too rigorous. Cranmer opted for marriage. He had moved into identification with certain Lutheran principles at this stage. Lutherans had reintroduced marriage to the priesthood.

Cranmer was not able to persuade Charles, Catherine's nephew, to support the annulment of his aunt's marriage.

When Cranmer was with Charles in Italy, he received a royal letter dated 1 October 1532. He was informed that he had been appointed as the Archbishop of Canterbury. William Warham had died.

Cranmer's appointment had been secured by the family of Anne Boleyn. She was being courted by Henry. He was directed to return to England. Henry had personally financed the papal bulls necessary for the promotion.

The promotion came as a surprise to London. Cranmer had only held minor positions of importance in the Church. He left Mantua on 19 November. He arrived in England at the beginning of January. The bulls arrived around 26 March 1533.

Thomas Cranmer was consecrated as a bishop on 30 March in St. Stephen's Chapel by John Longland, Bishop of Lincoln, John Vesey, Bishop of Exeter, and Henry Standish, Bishop of St. Asaph.

He had continued to work on the annulment proceedings even while they were waiting for the bulls. The annulment required greater urgency  after Anne announced her pregnancy.

Henry and Anne were secretly married on 25 January 1533 in the presence of a handful of witnesses. Cranmer didn't learn of the marriage until two weeks after the event.

Even though the pope had claimed supremacy over royalty in Christendom, the state of affairs in Italy was not secure. Clement VII had been elected in 1523 at the end of the Italian Renaissance.

Italy was divided between foreign interests. Spain and France were competing for influence over papal favor. The Ottoman empire had invaded eastern Europe. They were not far from Italy or the Vatican.

Charles V had inherited the crown of Aragon. The rule included the kingdoms of Naples, Sicily and Sardinia. It had controlled the Duchy of Milan a year before Charles ascended in 1519, but it was annexed by France after the Battle of Marignano in 1515.

Francis I of France had ascended in 1515. He had already gotten started in the Italian Wars that ran from 1494 to 1559. These wars included the Italian states as well France, Spain, England, the Roman Empire and the Ottomans.

Charles inherited a number of crowns in addition to Aragon. He was the heir to the House of Burgundy and the Habsburgs of Austria. Burgundy controlled the Netherlands. His holdings surrounded France.

The crown of Castille had started to expand the Spanish empire to the Americas. Charles documented disapproval for slavery, but it was allowed as a part of colonization with imperial expansion. The Spanish Inquisition was also used as a political tool.

Charles re-captured Milan in 1522 when his troops defeated the Franco-Swiss army at Bicocca. Francis crossed Lombardy where Milan along with a number of other cities fell in 1524.

Charles' forces captured Francis and crushed his army in the Battle of Pavia in Italy in 1525. Charles successfully held on to his Italian territories though they were invaded more during the wars that ran until 1559.

Charles sacked Rome in 1527 and imprisoned Clement VII. When his grandfather the emperor Maximilian died in 1530 the combined Spanish and Roman Empire for Charles was extensive. The Reformation was the only thing that stood in the way of his control of Europe.

The papal office was negotiating for peace between the Reformations and the expansion of the Spanish Empire. Clement VII was not in a position where he could honor Henry's petition for an annulment.

The pope couldn't officially celebrate the announcement of the marriage of Anne to Henry and her elevation to queen in 1533. He wanted to avoid an irreparable breach with England, but he provisionally excommunicated Henry and his advisers including Cranmer on 9 July. They could be restored to communion if Henry would repudiate Anne by the end of September.

Henry kept Anne as his wife. She gave birth to Elizabeth on 7 September. Cranmer baptized her and became one of her godparents.

Henry confirmed Thomas Cromwell as the vicegerent in April 1534. This made him the king's principal secretary and chief minister. The vicegerency instituted the reforms for England. The Act of Supremacy passed parliament in November of the same year. The king was declared the supreme head of the Church of England.

Anne miscarried a son in January 1536. The biblical prohibition that predicted childlessness as a consequence for his marriage to his brother's wife returned to haunt the king. He started to court Jane Seymour shortly after the miscarriage. Cromwell was commissioned to sue for divorce.

A number of bishops complained about Cranmer's appointment. John Stokesley, John Longland and Stephen Gardiner among others objected to his title. They argued that the Act of Supremacy did not define his role.

The break with Rome created doctrinal confusion. What did the new Church hold to be true? Ten Articles were adopted by clerical convocation in July 1536 as the first post-papal doctrinal statement of the English Church. The action attempted to appease both conservatives and reformers.

The first five articles defined doctrines that were believed to be necessary for salvation. The last five identified laudable Church ceremonies.

The core doctrine was justification by faith. Good works followed salvation by grace. This was a re-iteration of Lutheran doctrine.  Works of faith were defined as an extension of charity.

The Pilgrimage of Grace began in Yorkshire in October 1536. It spread to other parts of Northern England. Cumberland, Northumberland and north Lancashire were included.

The lawyer Robert Aske led the conservative protest of Henry VIII's break with the Roman Church, the Dissolution of Monasteries and other policies instituted by Cromwell. It was the most serious opposition to the English reform.

The government produced a forum to write a book after months of debate. The official title was The Institution of a Christian Man. It was informally known as the Bishops' Book. The book was initially proposed in 1537 in the first vicegerential synod convened by Cromwell for the Church.

Cromwell opened the proceedings. Cranmer and Foxe took on the chairmanship and the co-ordination as the synod progressed. Henry was most likely pre-occupied with the pregnancy of Jane Seymour. Edward was the first male heir. Jane died shortly after giving birth. Her funeral was held on 12 November.

Henry made amendments to the Bishops' Book later. He sent them to Cranmer, Sampson and others for comment. Cranmer's comments showed unambiguous support for reformed theology.   He endorsed justification by faith, sola fide and predestination. His argument did not convince the king.

The king and Cromwell arranged to have detailed discussions on forming a political and religious alliance in 1538. Discussions on theological differences were transferred to Lambeth Palace under Cranmer's chairmanship.

Cranmer's colleague, Edward Foxe, had died earlier in the year. He had sat on Henry's Privy Council. Henry chose Cranmer's conservative rival, Cuthbert Turnstall, to replace Foxe. The Germans sent a letter to the king expressing their three chief concerns regarding the English Reform.

The Lutherans objected to compulsory clerical celibacy, withholding the chalice from the laity and the maintenance of private masses for the dead. Turnstall intervened with the king to have him dismiss the concerns. Cranmer asked the Germans to stay, but they left on 1 October having made no substantial achievement.

Philipp Melanchthon, the Continential reformer, wrote several letters to Henry in 1539 to criticize his view of religion. He was especially critical of support for clerical celibacy. A delegation of Lutheran princes arrived in April to support Melanchthon's grievance.

Cromwell wrote a letter to support the Lutheran mission. The king did not change his position. He was dedicated to persuading the conservatives to stay with the Church of England.

Parliament met for the first time in three years on 28 April 1539. Cranmer was present. Cromwell was suffering from ill health. The House of Lords created a committee with customary religious balance between conservatives and reformers to examine and determine doctrine.

The committee didn't have enough time to do the detailed work needed for the revision. The Duke of Norfolk noted that the committee had not agreed on anything on 16 May. He proposed that the committee examine six doctrinal questions.

These questions shaped the Six Articles. The articles affirmed conservative belief in the real presence, clerical celibacy and private confession to a priest. Cranmer moved his wife and children out of England to safety as the Act of the Six Articles neared passage. The family had been kept quietly hidden up to this point in time.

Hugh Latimer and Nicholas Shaxton were forced to resign their dioceses given their outspoken opposition to the measures. The setback for the reformers was short lived. Henry was displeased with the promulgators and the results of the Acts. Cranmer and Cromwell were back in favor.

The archbishop was asked to write the preface for an English translation of the Bible. The Great Bible was first published in April 1539 with the direction of Cromwell.

Cromwell had also proposed a marriage between Henry and Anne Cleves, the sister of a German prince. The marriage could renew contacts with the Schmalkaldic League. Henry was not impressed by Anne when they first met on 1 January 1540, but he married her reluctantly on 6 January in a ceremony officiated by Cranmer.

Henry requested an annulment shortly after the ceremony. The king was in an embarassing situation. Cromwell suffered the consequences. The Duke of Norfolk took advantage of the weakened Cromwell. He was arrested on 10 June. He lost the support of his allies.

Cranmer wrote a letter to the king to defend Cromwell for his work, much like he had done for Anne Boleyn. Cromwell was removed from office.

A convocation was convened to consider the revision of the Bishops' Book in 1543. Cranmer chaired  the sub-committees, but the conservatives overturned many reform ideas including justification by faith. The unofficial title for the revision was changed to the King's Book. It was more conservative than the Bishops' Book had been.

Parliament passed the Act for the Advancement of True Religion on 10 May. It abolished "erroneous books" and restricted the reading of the Bible in English to those of noble status. Reformers were examined, forced to recant or imprisoned from May to August.

Cranmer was successful in publishing the first officially authorised service in the vernacular despite the charges leveled against him by conservatives. The prayers in the Exhortation and Litany were drawn from the work of John Chrysostom, Martin Luther and the Sarum rite and translated into English.

References to the saints were reduced. The work was published while Henry was at war with Scotland and France. The litany was penitential for procession in times of trouble. Short intercessory prayers by the priest were answered by shorter responses from the choir or congregation.

A coalition of conservatives targeted several reformers with links to Cranmer to block reforms in 1546. It is reported that some were executed. Some powerful reform minded nobles like Edward Seymour and John Dudley returned to England during the summer from overseas. They were able to turn the tide against the conservatives.

The Archbishop of Canterbury performed his final duties for the king on 28 January 1547. He gave a reformed statement of faith while holding Henry's hand. This was offered in lieu of last rites.

Cranmer grieved the death of the king. He grew a beard at this time as a demonstration of his grief. Continental reformers had grown beards to show their rejection of the old church. The significance of clerical beards was understood in England.

The Archbishop was among the executors of the king's final will that nominated Edward Seymour as Lord Protector for the boy king, Edward VI on 31 January 1547. The reformers became part of the establishment in the regency of Seymour.

Cranmer wrote four of the twelve homilies that were circulated to be read. One used the doctrine of justification to establish the primacy of faith in relation to good works. Monasticism was described as unnecessary with respect for the promotion of superstition in the devotion to images.

The Archbishop corresponded with Martin Bucer with respect for eucharistic views. Bucer condemned the corporeal real presence. This included the rejection of transubstantiation and the adoration of the elements.

The letter from Bucer was dated 18 November 1547. It was delivered by two Italian reformed theologians. Charles V's victory over the League at Muhlberg left England as the sole kingdom that gave sanctuary to persecuted reformers.

Bucer and Paul Fagius were forced to leave the city of Strasbourg in March 1549. Cranmer invited them to come to England. He promised that they would be placed in English universities.

They were wanted to train a new generation of preachers to assist in the reform of liturgy and doctrine. Jan Laski, the Polish reformer also accepted his invitation. Osiander and Melanchthon declined.

Conservatives and reformers wrote the Book of Common Prayer prior to the publication in 1548.

Cranmer publicly announced in a debate on the Eucharist in the House of Lords between 14 and 19 December that he had abandoned the doctrine of the corporeal real presence and believed the Eucharistic presence was only spiritual. He didn't win support from across the aisle.

Parliament backed the publication of the Prayer Book after Christmas by passing the Act of Uniformity in 1549. Clerical marriage was legalized as well.

The use of the new Prayer Book was made compulsory on 9 June 1549. A series of protests was triggered in Devon and Cornwall. The English language was not yet in common use. The protests are now called the Prayer Book Rebellion.

The protesters made a number of demands. The restoration of the Six Articles, the use of Latin for the mass, only the consecrated bread was to be offered to the laity, the restoration of prayers for souls in purgatory and the rebuilding of abbeys. Cranmer defended the official Church line in St. Paul's Cathedral. He wrote a letter to the regent that denounced the rebellion as evil.

Dissidents in the Privy Council banded together behind John Dudley to oust Seymour. He was initially imprisoned in the Tower of London, but was released on 6 February 1550 and returned to the Council. The archbishop was able to uproot some incumbent conservatives to replace them with reformers.

Cranmer worked on three major projects. The revision of canon law and the Prayer Book were two. He also sought to form a statement of doctrine.

He formed a committee to revise canon law in December 1551. He recruited Peter Martyr to revise the code in a way that would draw together all the reformed churches of Europe to counter the Council of Trent. This council was the Roman Catholic answer to the Protestant Reformation.

The leaders of the Continental reformers were invited to England for an ecumenical council. Melanchthon did not respond. Bullinger stated that neither could leave Germany as it was engaged in a war between the Emperor and the Lutheran princes. John Calvin said he was not able to attend.

The Prayer Book was revised again in 1552 with contributions from Bucer and Martyr. The Black Rubric was added to declare that no adoration was intended by kneeling for communion.

The statement of doctrine for the Church was recorded in the Forty-Two Articles was published in May 1553. The title page declared that the articles were agree upon by the Convocation and were published by the authority of the king.

While they were drawn up during the time of the convocation they were not published by authority of the king. The archbishop solicited subscriptions from bishops for the statement, but political events would eclipse the effort for a while.

Edward VI became will from tuberculosis. Mary, the daughter of Henry and Catherine, was Catholic. The Third Succession Act of 1543 had returned both Mary and Elizabeth to the line of succession. A number of judges proposed that Edward's cousin, Lady Jane Grey, should be crowned as queen.  Edward made it clear in his last will that Jane would succeed him. 

Cranmer was granted an audience with Edward in the presence of the councillars. Edward affirmed what he had written in his will. There were provincial revolts in Mary's favor when word of the will was spread. Support for Jane in the council fell. Mary was elevated. A number of bishops were detained. Cranmer was forced to write a recantation of his reforms.

Cranmer and four others were brought to trial for treason on 13 November 1553 and found guilty despite the recantation. The Privy Council ordered that Cranmer and others were to be transferred to Bocardo prison in Oxford to await another trial for heresy.

He was detained for 17 months. He was tried for heresy under papal jurisdiction. The verdict would come from Rome even though he was tried on English soil. Cranmer was deprived of the archbishopric. The royal authority was given permission to carry out their sentence on 4 December 1555.

Canon law allowed someone who recanted their error to be spared from punishment. Cranmer recanted Zwinglian and Lutheran doctrines and professed agreement with Catholic theology. Mary refused to grant a reprieve.

He was allowed to make a final recantation public at the University Church. He submit a speech in advance. It was published after his death. He deviated from the prepared script and renounced the recantations that he had written or signed with his own hand.

He stated that since his hand was responsible for his degradation, it should be burned first. His execution is dated to 21 March 1556. He was executed as a heretic to the Roman Catholic Church, but he died as a martyr for the principles of the English Reformation.

John Foxe put Cranmer's story into his book Acts and Monuments. It was first printed in 1563.

The Book of Common Prayer and the Thirty Nine Articles stand as a testimony to his work. When Elizabeth I rose to power she restored the Church of England with the Elizabethan Religious Settlement.

The Elizabethan Prayer Book was basically a reprint of the 1552 edition without the Black Rubric. The Forty Two Artices were never adopted by the Church, but they were altered in the area of eucharistic doctrine to form the Thirty-Nine Articles.

Cranmer was instrumental in the promotion of royal supremacy as a counter to the papal form. Henry VIII had reasonable grounds to complain that his realm was divided between his supporters and those who backed those whom the papal office favored among the other royals of the empire. The papal office had also made celibacy the standard for the priesthood.

Luther advocated for Christ as the authority for the Germanic kingdoms. He also re-instituted married clergy. He warned against rebellion from democracy. He supported monarchical leadership.

Democracy as promoted by Calvin was anti-monarchical in the placement of any local council under the direct authority of God. Had they not been so aggressive in rebellion for revolutionary change, the Calvinists would have encouraged local authority to manage local responsibility.

The English Reformation was more radical in opposition to celibacy and monasticism than the Lutherans. Royal leadership was eventually overthrown by reformed reforms, but it was re-instituted with greater authority for parliament than for the foreign king.

Parliament has been given the task of re-writing the legal code to meet modern standards for literacy.  The monarchy became native, but reforms to the legal code have not been completed.

Family succession is still favored as a social reflection of the royal family, but the status of being unmarried is not reduced to a criminal condition.

Thomas Cranmer
托马斯克兰默 
托馬斯克蘭默

托  Tuo    support         托  taku    requesting          To     と-   ト-       To   토   sat   
马   ma     horse             馬  ba        horse                ma    ま   マ          ma 마   hemp         
斯   si        this               斯  shi       this                   su      す     ス        seu 스   switch                   
克   Ke      restrain         克  koku   overcome          Ku      く      ク     Keu 크  greater                   
兰   lan     orchid            蘭  ran       orchid              ran   らん ラン     laen 랜  LAN             
默   mo     quiet              默  boku   silent                 ma    ま-    マ-       meo 머  what     

----------------------------------

The support for restraint in reform
kept the horse quiet during the storm.

=========================

Contrast
The Thirty-Nine Articles and the Westminster Confession

The Ordainment of Bishops is a significant difference. The WCF doesn't list the episcopacy as an office.

The Thirty-Nine Articles
The Church of England
1571
Text for Thirty Nine Articles

The articles were documented to express the doctrine for the Church of England. Most of the articles are summarized expressions drawn from the Ecumenical Councils. These statements of faith went through a rigorous process of scrutiny to define Christian theology.

A general concern against being too active in changing the world was expressed. Theological statements were used by aggressive activists to take property and to punish imagined offenses. The articles were written in a time when the political situation called for the consideration of the role that the claim to papal supremacy had played in shaping the competition among the royal houses.

The expansion of the Spanish Empire looked like it was going to command the entire Roman Empire. This would have been permissible in the state of affairs had it not been for the Inquisition and the return to slavery as instruments for the Spanish ascension.  The closer that the Spanish Empire got to taking over the political dimension of the alliance with Rome, the closer that the opposition got to adopting republican government.

Republican government has strength with respect for working to win election, but it suffers from liberal expenditure and deception in media expression in the competition to win. It suffered from the lack of legislation against slavery.

This is where the distinction between serfdom and slavery acquires critical importance. There was room for development with serfdom.  Slavery pretended to share the same capacity.

The conceptual distinction is subtle. Serfs were treated as part of the property whereas slaves were treated as property. There was also a trade for slaves that was not the case with serfs.

The difference in practice wasn't as subtle. Slaves were shackled with irons and whipped to induce submission or labor. Serfs were poor, but they eventually developed into a servant class in Great Britain. The class enjoyed a good deal of economic benefit by the time of Queen Victoria in the 20th century.

This said, the first of the thirty nine articles is about the Trinity. It includes a phrase that denies the incarnation of the Son. It states there "is but one living and true God, everlasting, without body, parts, or passions."

The intent may have been to discourage the passion of prejudice, but the inclusion of the phrase suggests that the incarnation of the Son as Christ in Jesus was not an event. It's worse than Docetism.

This was the doctrine that the suffering of Christ was not real. His body wasn't regarded as human. Belief in the incarnation holds that both natures were present in the second divine Person of the Trinity.

This is not just a technical point regarding something divorced from the world. It holds an important place with respect for the rate of change in political practice. The revolution that followed the Reformation did not legislate against slavery. The trade and the institution were included in the colonization of colonialism.

The liberal expenditure and deceptive media expression associated with winning elections corrupts the practice of democracy despite any nobility in intent. Parliamentarian and Congressional precipitation of profit  from war or military police action for officials and their support undermines the protection of civil rights as the intent for government. This precipitation is advanced with deceptive media expression.

While the collegial legislative bodies have done something significant in the transformation of the legal code for Constitutional law, the credibility for the achievement is negated by collateral damage whether it is accidental or intended.

There are other points that are debatable. While clergy are not commanded by God to remain single, neither should Church membership be obliged by custom to be married.  Knowledge of the Homilies is limited to those who have access.

The ordainment of women to the clergy ought to be allowed with seminary instruction as preparation for the position. This includes the position of bishop. While debate can be overly extended, it is best to limit argument to key points.

The key points of disagreement with the Roman Catholic Church are about the celibate clergy and transubstantiation. Transubstantiation lays claim to an embodiment through participation in the Eucharist that suggests too much of an impact on the world.

If the power of God is consumed and it is assumed that the power allows for the death penalty for disagreement in debate, then the overreach in palpable.  Jesus did not die on the cross to endorse tyranny at any level of society.

While the obvious disagreement was directed toward the Roman Catholic Church, there are even greater grounds for the same with Calvin's democracy and the attendant push for the revolutionary rejection of monarchy and the establishment of republican government.

Sola Scriptura


The Westminster Confession
Church of Scotland
1647
WCF with Proofs 1
With Proof Texts 2

The most striking difference between the Thirty-Nine Articles and the Westminster Confession is the emphasis on Scripture as the authority for the Church. The Anglican Communion describes ecclesiastical authority with scripture, tradition and the episcopacy. The difference is substantial.

It is necessary to note that civil authority is defined as ordained by God. While the civil magistrate has no right to interfere with preaching or the administration of sacraments, the Confession insists that the suppression of heresy and the prevention of corruption within the church as the magistrate's duty.

The Confession is more carefully written with respect for biblical justification. The Ecumenical councils used biblical justification in accord with the controversy of their time. Ecumenical statements are carefully phrased particularly with respect for theology.

There is agreement between the Articles and the Confession that the Roman Catholic tradition had become too sacramental. The Confession doesn't define a role for bishops. This creates a kind of deficiency with respect for instruction in the faith.

Self-declared charismatics are prone to rise up with a severe ascetic condition or a liberal rubric for government expenditure to take control of political or social authority.   Disruptive and disrespectful events are staged to demonstrate denominational "superiority."

The declaration of scripture as the sole authority doesn't leave room for the debate of biblical interpretation, but the challenge to civil authority entertains the threat of rebellion. Martin Luther was careful to discourage rebellion with his declaration of faith, but sola scriptura entertains rebellion against corruption. Luther crafted an inhibition against it, but the political condition for Germany still suffered in time due the excess of idealism.

The authorization for the Confession was approved by the English Parliament, but it was done at a time when Calvinism was entertained as the means to overthrow the British monarchy. It sanctioned the civil war against King Charles. Charles was  made into a victim of the time when rebellion was the prelude to revolution. It was viewed as the way to force political change upon established authority.

This mechanism undermines Common Law. If rebellion is authorized to oppose "corruption," then war, assassination, murder or terrorism are sanctioned as well. The definition for corruption becomes a tool of political convenience. Media expression is used to stir up resentment against established authority.

The Confession is well written as a carefully constructed expression of biblical scholarship, but the flaws are conducive to social unrest by the 'purity' of opposition to political corruption.

Petition and protest are subordinated to the coercion of political change with the threat of rebellion. or the socialism that seeks to institute itself as the political and social authority.

Efficient production becomes a regulatory agency that uses the market as a measure for public approval. It has a 'royal' form for democratic power insofar as it seeks excellence with respect for economic conditions.

----------------------------------------

R.M. Hare
3.21.1919 Backwell, UK
1.29.02 Ewelme, UK

Backwell

Backwell is a village with less than 5,000 people. It is 11 km (7 mi.) south of Bristol in Somerset, England. Somerset is located next to the Bristol Channel on the south coast. The channel is next to the Celtic Sea.

The name was listed in the Domesday Book in 1086 as ‘Bacoile.’ It means the ‘well on the back’ of the hill.

The parish was part of the hundred of Hartcliffe. Each hundred had a ‘fyrd’ which acted as the local defense force. The force was maintained by the frankpledge system. It was drawn from tithes to the Church. The hundreds extend back to the Anglo-Saxon era. This era preceded the Norman conquest in the 11th century.

The importance of the courts declined from the 17th century. Different administrative distinctions were drawn to define county government. Hundreds have been formerly abolished with the establishment of county courts in 1867.

The Local Government Act of 1894 was enacted by the Parliament of the United Kingdom to define county level responsibility.

R.M. Hare

Richard Mervyn was born at Backwell Down on 21 March 1919. The town is located outside Bristol. He was to be known professionally as R.M. Hare. His nickname was Dick.

His father, Charles Francis Aubone Hare, was director of the firm John Hare & Co. The company made paint and floor-cloth. His mother was Louise Kathleen Simonds. She was from a brewing and banking family.

His parents died while he was still young. He was cared for chiefly by guardians and relatives on his mother's side.

He was sent to school first at Copthorne in Sussex. He was a classical scholar at Rugby from 1932 to 1937. He was awarded a scholarship to Balliol College in 1937. He read two years of Greats before the outbreak of war.

Hare's mind was already turning towards moral philosophy despite his largely classical education. He ascribed this to conflict and guilt. There is the need to define an attitude towards fighting in relation to the feeling of guilt at living in moderate comfort.

He spent much time while still at Rugby working with the unemployed. He finally decided not to be a pacifist, but to join the Officer Training Corps.

He volunteered for service in the Royal Artillery when war broke out. He circumvented the results of a medical test in order to be permitted active service overseas.

Hare returned to Balliol to complete the four years of Greats after the war. He was offered a lectureship at Balliol even before he sat for Finals. This almost immediately became a fellowship.

He held the post of White's Professor of Moral Philosophy at the University of Oxford from 1966 until 1983. He subsequently taught for a number of years at the University of Florida. His meta-ethical theories were influential during the second half of the twentieth century.

Hare extended Immanuel Kant's Categorical Imperative by insisting that all the words used in such imperatives must be universals. There should be no specific references to the individual involved.

This was the universal part of his prescriptivism. Moral terms such as 'good', 'ought' and 'right' have two logical or semantic properties: universalizability and prescriptivity. He meant that moral judgments must identify the situation they describe according to a finite set of universal terms by the former.

Proper names are excluded, but not definite descriptions. Moral agents must perform those acts they consider themselves to have an obligation to perform whenever they are physically and psychologically able to do so.

Ignoring consequence in the application of an imperative led to nonsense. It did not make sense to say, "I ought to do X", then to fail to do it.

Another example of an absurdity was the application of the maxim "do not steal" to the discovery of terrorist plans to blow up a nuclear facility.

He was critical of John Rawls theory of justice. Rawls approached the topic from a subjective perspective, then claimed that it was objective later. His theory reduced justice to an absurdity.

Richard Hare
S.理查德哈尔
T.理查德哈爾

理 Li    reason        理 ri       logic                       Ri   り         リ                  Li   리 Lee             
查 cha  see            查 no kanji                            cha ちゃ-  チャ-               cha  차 car   
德 de   morality    德 toku    morality                 do   ど        ド                   deu  드 de
哈 Ha   yawn          哈 go      school of fish        Hea へあ ヘア                  He    헤 he
尔 er    you             爾 ore     you                                                                   eo    어 uh

-------------------------------

Emotion plays a role in the reason of morality.
Responsibility gains definition with respect for locality
and generality.

=======================

Qian Lin 3.11.1991 Hangzhou, Zhejiang, China                       
钱琳
リンリンOcean Butterflies International
Lullaby Game

Hangzhou

Hangzhou is located in the northern part of Zhejiang in China. It is the capital and the most populous city for the province. It sits at the head of Hangzhou Bay. The bay separates Shanghai from Ningbo.

The city grew to prominence as the southern end of the Grand Canal. The canal is the longest and oldest artificial river in the world. It starts in Beijing and runs 1,776 km (1100 mi.). It links the Yellow to the Yangtze River. The various sections of the canal were first connected during the Sui dynasty (581-618 CE).

Zhejiang sits on the east coast of China. It is next to the East China Sea. It is north of Fujian.
Linlin

Qian Lin was born in Hangzhou, China on March 11, 1991.

She is better known as Linlin in Japan. She joined Hello Project Egg for training in song and dance after being introduced to Tsunku. She had been scouted by a local talent agency in China as early as 1999. She was in the second grade.

It was officially announced that she would be part of the 8th generation of Morning Musume along with Junjun and Mitsui Aika on March 15, 2007.  Linlin and Junjun were the foreign students' for the Asian market.

Linlin was designated as the leader for Minimoni in 2009 by Tsunku.

She graduated from Morning Musume along with Junjun and Eri Kamei in the fall of 2010. She also graduated from Hello! Project and Minimoni.

She returned to China after graduation. Her first solo single was released in 2013.

She valued her time with Morning Musume so much that she started to produce songs for the Idol School in China in 2015 and 2016.

She revealed that she had been married since November 2014 on a Japanese TV show in June 2016. She had given birth to  a child in September 2015.

------------------------------

钱 Qian  money        琳 Rin  jewel     Rin  りん  リン     Lin 린  Lin     
琳 Lin   gem          琳 Rin  jewel      Rin  りん  リン    Lin 린  Lin

-------------------------------

The value of money is dependent upon gold.
The beauty of a jewel has a value untold.

===================